![]() |
Shabbat Shalom: Parshat Chaya Sarah Genesis 23:1-25:18
By Shlomo Riskin |
Efrat, Israel – Why does the Torah devote an entire
chapter — no less than 20 verses — to the burial of Sarah in this week’s
portion? Why does the sacred Biblical text discuss with such detail Abraham’s
procurement of a proper burial place?
After all, until this point no one’s death has evoked this much concern.
Biblical characters are born, they live and they die. Even Noah receives no
special eulogy; it’s flat and perfunctory: “All of Noah’s days were 950
years and he died” (Gen. 9:29). That’s it.
So all the devotion, bargaining and patience that Abraham expresses in making
sure that Sarah rests properly in eternal peace seem all the more worthy of
our scrutiny. A clue to the answer can be found in the oxymoron of a phrase
Abraham uses to describe himself to the children of Heth: Ger v’toshavav,
alien and resident (23:4), two opposite descriptions!
Why does Abraham describe himself in such am¬bivalent, almost paradoxical
terms? From one perspective, the phrase exquisitely captures Abraham in exile,
with one foot here and one foot elsewhere, on the one hand, tax paying
citizens mastering the legal system, cul¬ture and language down to its
subtlest nuances, but at the same time ready to leave on a moment’s notice
when the host country decides that we Jews are aliens after all. As Tevye
wryly remarks when he and his co-religionists are forced to leave Anatevka “that’s
why we Jews always wear a hat; we must be ready to get out at a moment’s
notice.” And remember that when Abraham was negotiating with the Hittites,
they were in control of Canaan!
But even more profoundly, the phrase alien-resident expresses the realization
that every human being’s connection to the world is temporary, his existence
tempered by the experiences that remind him of mortality. Every one of us
lives in this transient world as a resident-alien. As we shall see in the Book
of Leviticus, we read G-d’s command that once every 50 years — the Jubilee
year— all purchased lands must return to the original owners. The Bible
explains, “And the land shall not be sold into in perpetuity, for the land
is Mine; you are strangers and settlers with Me” (Lev 25:23). Nothing in
this world really belongs to us, is really permanent, not even “real eastate.”
Perhaps it is because Abraham is aware of the resident stranger condition of
humanity, that he seeks a permanent burial site for Sarah and is ultimately
willing to pay so much money for it. Indeed, the chapter ends with the
declaration that the cave became the “uncontested property” of Abraham.
This may very well be the source for the principle expressed in the Ethics of
the Fathers: “This world may be compared to a foyer before the world to
come; prepare yourself in the foyer so that you may properly enter the living
room” (4:21).
Abraham understands death differently than anyone who ever lived before him,
and therefore sees the grave-site as an “eternal” monument, which stands
for an existence beyond the body’s expiration. After all, the corollary to
the fact that every person is created “in the Divine image,” infused with
‘a portion of the Divine from Above; is that we are endowed with a piece of
eternity a soul, which lives beyond our physical existence. Hence, the Jewish
customs of death, the significance of kever yisrael — a Jewish burial —is
derived from this week’s portion.
Why do we light a yahrtzeit candle? Why is cremation a major sin in Judaism?
Why yizkor and kaddish? Why do we gather together when the burial monument (matzeva)
is unveiled? All of these customs are based on the idea that there is an
eternity, a reality based on the beyond of this reality, a life of the spirit
which, if properly nurtured in this world — the temporary world for the
eternal world —is much more significant than the day a soul leaves its
eternity for its temporary sojourn down below.
To be sure, the kind of life a person lives in this world determines his
portion in the eternal world, and the bettering of the world here and now is a
most legitimate Jewish goal. Nevertheless, once a person accepts the
limitations of this world and the limitless nature of the next one, everything
he does takes on a different cast.
Maimonides, the arch-rationalist, usually stresses that Judaism’s purpose
for life is to improve this world. Nevertheless, the major thrust in his Laws
of Repentance deals with the world to come and the eternity of the soul.
Indeed, for Maimonides, the most significant human endeavor in this world is
in establishing an abiding relationship with one’s spirit, with one’s God,
with one’s eternity; that is what brings eternal life.
Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzato (1707-1747), in his work “Paths of the Righteous,”
asks: “Why were we put in this world in the first place?” He answers that
“we are put in this world to enjoy it.” Yet but what brings true
enjoyment? Only spiritual achievement. What is physi¬cal will, after all,
eventually disappear or dissolve… that is why, he argues, too much of
anything physical will make you retch. Only the spiritual and eternal
ultimately pro¬vides real pleasure.
Ernest Becker, in his masterful work Denial of Death, queries why a physical
act as pleasurable and wondrous as the sexual union has linguistically become
the source for words of destruction and curses, “dirty” jokes, locker room
hu¬mor. He theorizes that anything that is physical cannot give a person
consummate joy because it only re¬minds him that one day he, too, will
disappear. Indeed, the British poets use the word “death” to describe the
sexual orgasm.
Hence, the human response to the sexual act is ambivalent. It’s pleasure has
a bitter undertaste since it reminds the individual of his eventual mortality.
Becker likewise concludes that the most crucial human enterprise is the search
for immortality, the connection with that aspect of our essence which lives
beyond death.
Abraham establishes a “Jewish” burial plot, for which he pays an enormous
amount of money, in order to teach that there is a life of the spirit that
defies and tran¬scends death.
Perhaps this is why the portion is called Chayei Sarah --the life of Sarah —
because even after her death, Sarah lives. The righteous, according to the
Talmud (Brakhot 18a), are alive even after their deaths, while the wicked are
dead even when they’re alive. Only connection with the eternal spirit brings
eternal life.
Shabbat Shalom