



|
 |
 |
 |

Shabbat Shalom: Parshat Shoftim
Deut. 16:18-21:10
By Shlomo Riskin
Efrat, Israel – “Judges and officers shall you establish in all
of your gates… and you shall come to the Kohen – Teachers, to the
Judges who will be [functioning] in those days. And you shall do in
accordance with what they tell you… And you shall surely set up for
yourselves a King …” (Deut 16:18, 17: 8-10, 14).
Fascinatingly enough, the Bible records a number of different and
distinctive leadership roles in the Biblical period in Israel, each
of which has to be adequately defined and understood: King, Judge,
Kohen-Priest and Prophet. Each of these functionaries played a major
role; however, only when all four leadership roles operated in
tandem, with each playing his “instrument” to perfection, and when
at the same time each one successfully served to check and balance
the others, could the Israelite nation hope to become a “holy nation
and Kingdom of Priest-teachers.”
The King must be the orchestra leader. He must serve as Chief
Executive Officer par excellence, responsible for setting the
theoretical policy and effectuating the proper functioning of a
government dedicated to being a beacon of light and enlightenment, a
model of morality and freedom, to all the nations of the world. The
King must be the symbol of the King of all Kings, both for his
nation as well as for all of humanity, and he must therefore discard
the normal trappings of a powerful monarchy – the acquisition of
many houses (Volvos today), the marrying of many wives (or
“cavorting” with many mistresses) and the amassing of much gold and
silver – in favor of his always bearing on his person a second Torah
Scroll. (Deut. 17:15-20; Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Hagiga
3).
The next most critical functionaries were the judges, and when
qualified, their legislative skills might bring them to the
Sanhedrin, the highest court in the land. The Sanhedrin dealt
with great national questions; it sat within the Holy Temple
borders, in the office of Hewn Stone or clear-cut decisions (Lishkat
HaGazit), and was presided over by the Prince or President (Nasi),
who traditionally hailed from the family of Judah. These Judges not
only decided the law which was to be followed by Israel, especially
those laws which were involved in dispute and dissension within the
ranks of rabbinic leadership but even more importantly, the
Sanhedrin had to extract and extrapolate new laws in response to
changing circumstances; the critical function of the Sanhedrin was
nowhere in greater evidence than after the destruction of the Second
Temple, when our Sages transformed Judaism from a Temple-centered,
Priestly-directed nation to a very different “Prayer-and-Repentance”
oriented people, through whose legislative body of Elders the
external Divine Voice from Sinai would continue to be heard
throughout the generations.
But perhaps the most fundamental of all functionaries were the
Priest and Prophet, the Kohen and Navi, who had to complement each
other despite (or perhaps because of) the natural tensions which (of
necessity) developed between them, and whose awe-inspiring presence
– especially that of the prophet – is so tragically absent today.
I have previously commented on the fact that the Kohen-priest wore
unique and special garments, and that the position of Kohen-priest
was completely dictated by pedigree: only if your father was a Kohen-priest
could you be a Kohen-priest. The Kohen represented the march of
tradition, the ritual laws regarding praying and eating, ascetic
fasting and celebratory feasting, the minutiae of religious
observances from the moment the Jew rises in the morning to the time
he/she goes to sleep at night, the life-cycle events from cradle to
grave.
But as crucially important as ritual detail may be for our Jewish
continuity and eternity, and as an expression of the utter
seriousness with which we look at Divine service, compulsive
obsession surrounding our observances can destroy the very
spirituality our religion is desperately attempting to foster, and
turn a sincere inner religious emotion into an external “show” of
one-upmanship. This was the kind of degeneration occurring within
the sacred walls of the Holy Temple itself, and it caused the
prophets to speak out against the hypocritical sacrifices and the
meaningless festival celebrations which left widows and orphans in
the lurch.
Today, we can see the tension between ethics and ritual in the area
of Kashrut. The major purpose of kashrut certainly included
uniting the Jewish people into a cohesive, unique and separate
ethnic entity, dedicated to the preservation of our faith. Instead,
in the contemporary Jewish world, the results are the exact
opposite. Is there any force in contemporary Jewish life which
divides the Jewish people to a greater extent than Kashrut
observance! More often than not, fervid religiosity is measured by
which homes and restaurants I will not eat in or which Kashrut
certifications I will not accept. Are we truly preserving the march
of Jewish generations and the importance of binding traditions from
parents to children when children refuse to eat in Sabbath observing
parental homes because their parents do not abide by a stringency of
“Kosher” milk (halav yisrael) or accept the Chief Rabbinate
permissibility of selling the top soil of Israel to the Arabs during
the Sabbatical year!
In Biblical times it was the prophet - devoid of special clothes or
special pedigree – who reminded the Kohen priests as well as the
nation that G-d desires first and foremost service of the heart, and
that the true purpose of the ritual was to bring Jews together in
love and compassion. The prophet decreed animal sacrifices
and festival observances as meaningless, reduced to empty forms and
hollow attempts at bribing G-d, if devotees of ritual forget the
orphan, the widow and the homeless (Isaiah 1). Tragically, the
courageous voice of the prophet, whose major task is to properly
define religious priorities, is sadly lacking today within our
institutionalized, and all too often ossified, Jewish community.
Shabbat Shalom
Return to Ohr Torah Stone
|